Pricing

The Credit Card Wall That Slowed Render's Growth

The Mistake

You ask for a credit card before anyone can try your product. A trial with a card up front feels like the responsible choice. You only get serious users, and nobody burns your money.

Anurag Goel made that call at Render. There was no free tier, just a week-long trial that needed a card. On The SaaS Podcast, he agreed that skipping the free tier was one of his most expensive mistakes.

The cost wasn't the people who tried Render and left. It was the people who never tried it at all.

Why Founders Make It

Thinking word of mouth will carry people past the friction. Anurag thought a great onboarding experience, a low price and a friend's recommendation would get people over their hesitation. It didn't. "Render was unknown back then."

Thinking free users will drain the bank. For Render this fear was real. It sells compute, and "the free tier really costs you." But for a SaaS company, he says a free tier is a given.

Thinking a low price is close enough to free. It isn't. At $7 a month, the price wasn't the problem. The card was. "People just don't want to give your credit card" to a company they haven't heard of, "even if they've heard of it from a friend."

How Anurag Lost Momentum

Render launched publicly in October 2019 with billing in place and the week-long trial. Even with the trial, "a lot of people didn't even take the trial because they just didn't want to give us their credit card."

It stayed that way until late 2021, when Render finally rolled out a free tier. Result: signups "started going up much faster."

Then, in July 2022, Heroku ended its free tier. Developers went looking for a new home, and Render had a free door open. Signups "more or less tripled."

  • Signups: 5,000 developers a month (July 2022)
  • Signups today: almost half a million a month

Anurag calls the Heroku timing luck. But the luck only paid off because the free tier already existed. With the old card-first trial, that wave would have hit the same wall.

The Fix (If You're Making It Now)

  1. This week, remove the card from the first try. A free tier or a no-card trial. Pick whichever you can afford.
  2. This month, cap what free costs you. Render's free apps go to sleep when no requests come in. Anurag kept the free tier at "a reasonable percentage of our revenue," and it became a smaller share over time.
  3. Keep it honest. Anurag's warning on the other side: give away too much and you grow fast, then find out you're selling a dollar for pennies. Free should get people to try the product, not stand in for paying.

The Signal to Watch

Track one number every week: of the people who land on your signup page, how many start a trial? If lots of people show up from referrals and few start, the card is your wall. After you remove it, watch the same number, then watch how many free users turn into paying ones.

Ready to build your SaaS with founders who get it?

Join thousands of SaaS founders getting weekly insights and proven strategies from real founder conversations.

Free weekly newsletter · No spam